Verdict: NYX Fat Oil Lip Drip Plumping Lip Gloss ($9) is a 81% match dupe for Charlotte Tilbury Magic Lip Oil Crystal Elixir ($32) — 72% cheaper for a comparable formula. The two formulas share 3 of 6 key ingredients, including jojoba seed oil and squalane. Full price and ingredient comparison below.
By the BeautyFlow Research Team · Updated July 2026
The Original
Magic Lip Oil Crystal Elixir
$32The Dupe
Save 72%
Fat Oil Lip Drip Plumping Lip Gloss
$9Discovered by the beauty community
Know who found this first?
Ingredient Comparison
3 shared ingredients
Frequently Asked Questions
Is NYX Fat Oil Lip Drip Plumping Lip Gloss a good dupe for Charlotte Tilbury Magic Lip Oil Crystal Elixir?
Yes — NYX Fat Oil Lip Drip Plumping Lip Gloss is a 81% match for Charlotte Tilbury Magic Lip Oil Crystal Elixir based on ingredient and formula comparison, at 72% less ($9 vs $32). The two formulas share 3 of 6 key ingredients, including jojoba seed oil and squalane.
How much cheaper is NYX Fat Oil Lip Drip Plumping Lip Gloss than Charlotte Tilbury Magic Lip Oil Crystal Elixir?
NYX Fat Oil Lip Drip Plumping Lip Gloss costs $9 versus $32 for Charlotte Tilbury Magic Lip Oil Crystal Elixir — a saving of $23 (72% less).
What is the difference between Charlotte Tilbury Magic Lip Oil Crystal Elixir and NYX Fat Oil Lip Drip Plumping Lip Gloss?
The main difference is price — Charlotte Tilbury Magic Lip Oil Crystal Elixir costs $23 more. The two formulas share 3 of 6 key ingredients, including jojoba seed oil and squalane. See the full ingredient table on this page for the exact overlap.
Get Alerts for New Charlotte Tilbury Dupes
Be first to know when we verify a cheaper match for Magic Lip Oil Crystal Elixir — plus weekly top dupe finds
Community Photos
Community Discussion
Build Your Complete Routine
Get personalized product recommendations with dupes for every step — tailored to your skin type, concerns, and budget.
Get My Routine